The dispute between criminal defence solicitors and the Minister for Justice over payment for criminal legal aid work in the District Court has been resolved. Solicitors who had withdrawn their services have returned to work.
What the dispute was about
On 1 July 2026 new regulations replaced the previous payment structure for District Court legal aid cases with a single flat fee of €520 for each accused person. The fee applied regardless of how many charges or court appearances were involved, and separate legal aid certificates were no longer granted for separate cases against the same person. Under the previous scheme, a solicitor was paid €240 for a first appearance and about €60 for each later one.
Many criminal defence solicitors withdrew their services in protest. The action lasted more than four months and led to thousands of cases being adjourned.
The High Court ruling
On 3 November 2026 the High Court found that key parts of the new payment model were grossly unfair and illogical, and that they went beyond the Minister’s powers under the Criminal Justice (Legal Aid) Act 1962. Talks between the Department of Justice and the Law Society followed.
What was agreed
Agreement was announced on 10 November 2026. Under its terms:
- The €520 flat fee remains the standard payment.
- €780 is paid where two separate and distinct cases against the same accused are brought on the same day.
- €1,040 is paid for three or more such cases.
- An enhanced fee of €780 applies to domestic violence cases, cases involving children, and cases where the accused is remanded in custody.
- Multiple legal aid certificates for one accused will no longer be issued.
The Law Society said the agreement addressed its two main concerns: the treatment of separate cases listed on the same day, and payment for longer and more complex cases.
What this means if you have a case
- If your case was adjourned during the dispute, it will be given a new date. Check with your solicitor or the court office.
- If you qualify for criminal legal aid, you can again be assigned a solicitor in the usual way.
- If you have received a summons or been charged, get advice before your first court date. See our criminal law page.
Some related court challenges remain listed before the High Court, so further changes to the scheme are possible.
Talk to us
If you have questions about a criminal matter before the courts, call us on 01 901 1355, email info@rnlsolicitors.ie or book a consultation.
This article is general information, not legal advice.