Judicial Review

Judicial review is a High Court procedure for challenging the way a public body has made, or failed to make, a decision. In immigration matters it is often the only way to challenge a refusal that carries no right of appeal, or to deal with an application that has been left undecided. Our immigration solicitors in Dublin advise on whether judicial review is open to you and act in proceedings before the High Court.

What is judicial review?

In judicial review the High Court looks at whether a decision was made lawfully and fairly. It does not re-decide the application or substitute its own view. If the court finds that the decision-maker acted unlawfully, it can set the decision aside and send it back to be made again.

When is it used in immigration cases?

  • Refusals with no appeal, such as a refusal of naturalisation.
  • Refusals where an appeal or review has already failed, such as visa, family reunification or EU Treaty Rights decisions.
  • Deportation orders and related decisions.
  • International protection decisions.
  • Delay, where an application has not been decided. See delayed applications.

What can the High Court order?

  • An order setting aside (quashing) an unlawful decision.
  • An order requiring the decision-maker to make a decision.
  • A declaration about your legal rights.

Time limits

Time limits for judicial review are strict and short. Many immigration decisions must be challenged within 28 days of the date you are notified of the decision. For other decisions, the general limit is three months from the date the grounds first arose. The court will extend time only for good reason, so take advice as soon as you receive a decision.

How the process works

  1. Assessment. We review the decision and your file and advise whether there are grounds for a challenge.
  2. Letter before action. Where appropriate, we write to the decision-maker first.
  3. Application for leave. We apply to the High Court for permission to bring the case.
  4. Response. The State sets out its position.
  5. Hearing or resolution. The case is heard by a judge, or is resolved by agreement beforehand.

Costs

At your consultation we take full instructions and give you a fee estimate for the work involved. We also explain the costs risks of court proceedings before you decide whether to go ahead.

Frequently asked questions

Will the court grant my application?

No. The court can set aside an unlawful decision or order that a decision be made, but the application itself goes back to the decision-maker.

Do I have to appeal first?

Usually, where an appeal or review is available, you are expected to use it before seeking judicial review.

Can I stay in Ireland while the case is ongoing?

That depends on your circumstances and the orders made by the court. We advise on this at the outset.

Speak to an immigration solicitor

Call us on 01 901 1355, email info@rnlsolicitors.ie, message us on WhatsApp, book an appointment online or use our enquiry form.

This page is general information, not legal advice.

Let us take it from here.