Employers Charged With Employing Workers Without Permission

It is a criminal offence in Ireland to employ someone who does not have permission to work here. Companies, business owners and directors are prosecuted for this following inspections by the Workplace Relations Commission or Garda investigations. If your business has been inspected, questioned or charged, our solicitors in Dublin can advise you and defend you in court. We also advise on immigration law, so we understand both sides of these cases.

What is the offence?

The Employment Permits Act 2024 makes it an offence to employ a non-EEA national in the State unless they hold a valid employment permit, or an immigration permission that allows them to work without one, such as Stamp 4. It is also an offence for the worker to work without permission.

Common situations include:

  • employing someone whose permit or immigration permission has expired;
  • employing a student beyond the hours their Stamp 2 allows;
  • employing someone on a permit tied to a different employer or role;
  • engaging workers through an agency or subcontractor who turn out not to have permission.

Penalties

  • In the District Court: a fine of up to €4,000 and/or up to 12 months’ imprisonment.
  • On indictment: a fine of up to €250,000 and/or up to 10 years’ imprisonment.

A conviction can also lead to more frequent inspections, refusal of future employment permit applications for your business, and damage to your reputation. Directors and managers can face personal liability in some circumstances.

The defence: reasonable steps

It is a defence for an employer to show that it took all such steps as were reasonably open to it to make sure it was complying with the law. What counts as reasonable depends on the facts, but evidence usually includes:

  • copies of passports, Irish Residence Permit cards and employment permits taken before the person started work;
  • records showing when permissions were checked and rechecked before expiry;
  • written procedures for right-to-work checks;
  • contracts and checks for workers supplied by agencies or subcontractors.

There is no official checklist for these checks, which is why the facts of each case, and how they are presented to the court, matter so much.

How we can help

  • Advice during a Workplace Relations Commission inspection or Garda investigation.
  • Representing the company and its directors in interviews.
  • Reviewing the evidence and preparing your defence.
  • Representing you in the District Court or Circuit Court.
  • Where appropriate, presenting mitigation to keep the penalty as low as possible.
  • Putting proper right-to-work checks in place so it does not happen again.
  • Advising on the immigration position of the workers concerned, including whether they can regularise their status.

Frequently asked questions

We did not know the employee’s permission had expired. Is that a defence?

Not on its own. The question is whether you took all reasonable steps to check. Records of your checks will be central to your defence.

Should we dismiss the employee straight away?

Take advice first. Dismissing someone without fair procedures can lead to an unfair dismissal claim, even where their permission has lapsed.

Can we still apply for employment permits after a conviction?

A conviction can count against future applications. This is one reason to defend a prosecution properly and to put compliant procedures in place.

See also our pages on work permits and criminal law.

Speak to a solicitor

If your business has been inspected or charged, contact us early. Call us on 01 901 1355, email info@rnlsolicitors.ie or use our enquiry form. All enquiries are treated in confidence.

This page is general information, not legal advice.

Let us take it from here.